Arguing with an atheist is like watching someone build a house out of fog. They speak with confidence, but the moment you push for evidence, the whole thing disappears. That happened again with CB. He believes in abiogenesis. He believes in evolution. He believes both ideas are proven when they are still nothing more than faith wrapped in lab coats. When he felt the ground slipping under him, he tried to hit me with black holes. That was his big move. Not biology. Not chemistry. Not evidence. Black holes. It was a clean deflection. It was not an answer. I decided to let him walk through his own logic and see where it led. What followed was a perfect illustration of how some atheists argue. Loud claims. No sources. No math. No peer-reviewed work. Just confidence without knowledge. This article breaks down the exchange. You will see what CB claimed, what the data shows, and why the peer-reviewed literature leaves no room for his version of the story.